The Genocide Convention.
The Hypothetical: The Republic of Amistan has brought an action in the International Court of Justice [ICJ] against Malevoland, for violations of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. Both are parties to the convention. There is ample proof in expert reports and the media that Malevoland has targeted a religious minority group by:
1) Confining and, in some cases, executing the group’s religious and political leaders who have resisted Malevoland’s assimilation policies, and
2) Removing children from the group to place them in camps where the children are forbidden from speaking the language of their group or engaging in other cultural practices.
At this point it is unclear whether Malevoland intends to return the children. The ICJ’s jurisdiction in this matter, under article IX of the Genocide Convention, hinges on whether Malevoland’s actions amount to genocide under article II of the convention. You will conduct an interpretation of the Genocide Convention in order to offer an opinion on whether either of the two acts listed above amount to genocide. At issue is whether the Genocide Convention excludes cultural genocide .
The Assignment As we have seen, there is wide disagreement among courts and scholars over whether the Genocide Convention reaches acts intended to destroy a group culturally, as opposed to physically or biologically. You will write an interpretation of the Genocide Convention focusing on this issue. Your interpretation should be no longer than 5 pages (1,250 words) and should follow this outline:
1. What if anything does the Genocide Convention’s text say about cultural genocide?
2. Applying VCLT article 32, to article 2 of the Genocide Convention, is recourse to supplementary means of interpretation permitted to clarify this issue?
3. What do the Genocide Convention’s drafters say about:
a. Whether all acts of cultural genocide were excluded.
b. Whether the parties intended to include only physical-biological (material) destruction, thereby excluding all incidents where a perpetrator intends cultural destruction.
4. Conclusion: Tell me whether the Genocide Convention contains acts of cultural genocide and/or reaches incidents of cultural destruction.
Do Malevoland’s acts (of removing and selectively killing a religious group’s leaders and forcibly transferring its children) amount to genocide and therefore trigger ICJ jurisdiction?
This is a factual exercise. Each of your opinions and assertions needs to be backed up by reference to one of the textual sources listed below. If you can’t support your argument by pointing to a treaty, a report, or summary record, then your argument is not grounded in fact and should be abandoned. The word limit on this assignment is tight. You will need to write concisely, which means you will need to edit your text, repeatedly.
Leave time for this. Words that are not your own need to be within quotation marks and cited. Ideas you’ve borrowed need to be cited. You should cite specific treaty provisions or resolutions in your text like this: (VCLT art 31(b); UNGA Res 96(1)). UN documents should be cited by providing the document title and its UN Doc #, like this: (Secretariat’s Draft UN Doc E/447). You can cite 6th Committee meetings like this: (6th Comm SR.83, comment of Mr. Abdoh). Cite plenary sessions like this: (UNGA 178th Plen Mtg, comment of Mrs. Ikramullah). Please use a normal, easy to read 12 point font in black. Your Research In 1996 the International Law Commission [ILC] issued an influential commentary on the Genocide Convention where it asserted that:
1) the Genocide Convention’s drafters intended to exclude all acts of cultural genocide and
2) that this proves the drafters intended it to reach only incidents where the perpetrator had intended to destroy a protected group’s physical or biological existence, excluding situations where the perpetrator intended to destroy a group by attacking its cultural functioning. Begin by reviewing the ILC statement.
Then, review articles 31 and 32 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties [VCLT] which provide the standard of interpretation.
What Does the Treaty Say? Conduct an interpretation of the text of the Genocide Convention according to VCLT article 31, placing article 2’s terms in the convention’s broader context including its preamble, which references UN General Assembly Resolution article 96(1).
What does article 2 of the Genocide Convention have to say about cultural issues?
Does the type of groups singled out for protection say anything about the Genocide Convention’s concerns?
Are any acts of cultural genocide included among article 2’s prohibited acts?
What does UNGA Res 96(1) indicate about the General Assembly’s concerns in outlawing genocide?
What does the chapeau say about destruction?
Is physical destruction mentioned in any of article 2’s prohibited acts and does this mean anything in regard to its other provisions?
Is Recourse Permitted?
Considering VCLT article 32, is the Genocide Convention’s language so vague or absurd on the issue of cultural genocide as to justify recourse to supplementary means of interpretation?
Explain. Draft Distinctions Next, turn to the Genocide Convention’s preparatory work asking what these materials indicate about the drafters’ intent. The ILC finds significance in the fact that the convention’s first draft, compiled by the Secretariat, and second draft, compiled by an Ad Hoc Committee on genocide, contained provisions addressing cultural genocide while the final draft, compiled by the Sixth (Legal) Committee Draft did not.
Is the elimination of the cultural genocide provisions significant?
What do the Sixth Committee Delegates Say?
Most of the debate on cultural genocide happened in the 63rd, 64th, 65th, 66th, 83rd, and 108th meetings. Review these records.
What are the delegates saying?
The cultural genocide provision was voted down in the 83rd meeting of the Sixth Committee.
How significant is this?
A statement by a chairman is given precedence in explaining a committee’s views. But what did other delegates make of his statement that the vote concerned “whether or not the convention would cover cultural genocide?” (Pay attention to the comments by Mr. Pérez Perozo and Mr. Kahn in the 83rd meeting.)
Is Article 2(e) an Act of Cultural Genocide? Look at the Sixth Committee’s 82nd meeting.
What do the delegates have to say about the forcible transfer of children and its relation to cultural genocide?
Is there a majority view on the issue and if so, what is it?
Destruction: Physical-Biological and Cultural?
Novic and Schabas claim the delegates never engaged the characteristics of genocidal destruction. Look at the discussion of the French and Soviet proposed amendments in the Sixth Committee’s 72nd and 73rd meetings.
Are the delegates discussing the issue of physical and biological (material) destruction versus cultural destruction?
What, if anything, do the votes on these amendments say about their intentions?
What Did Delegates in the UN General Assembly Plenary Meetings Say About Cultural Genocide?
Delegates in the Plenary Sessions debated the Sixth Committee’s draft and decided not to change anything. What did they say about cultural genocide?
Did they support adding a cultural genocide provision?
Did they state whether they believed the acts prohibited under article 2 might be acts of cultural as well as physical-biological (material) genocide?
Did they address the issue of whether they intended to prohibit attacks on a group’s cultural existence?
Scholarly opinion is a source of international law and you have now read several scholars whose work might be relevant (Lauterpacht, Novic, and Schabas). If it helps your argument, feel free to cite and/or quote these sources. Finally, all the UN documents listed here (and many, many more) are available on the UN Official Document System website, where you can search be doc #: https://documents.un.org/prod/ods.nsf/home.xsp Get homework help.
Top Quality and Well-Researched Papers
We offer top-quality and well-researched assignment papers at low prices. We believe in offering the best quality services as we care about your grades, academic performance, and success. Our writers range from masters and Ph.D. graduates to professors. Our panel of expert academic writers does not rest until they are 100% sure your essay will score you an A+ only.
Professional and Experienced Academic Writers
Our writing company has the best panel of experienced academic and business writers. Our writers have experience of up to 9 years in the writing industry. They will go the extra mile to make sure you are handing in a quality A+ paper. If you are a student searching for any academic help, I advise you to seek for our experts' help.
Free Unlimited Revisions
Our clients frequently ask if they will be liable to free revisions once they place an assignment order with us. However, how many times you ask for revisions, our academic experts will help you. Either way, there is no need to worry as we provide free revisions. We are always after our clients’ satisfaction, and we are very proud to say that all our clients are satisfied with our writing services.
Prompt Delivery and 100% Money-Back-Guarantee
We are strict when it comes to assignments deadlines. We make sure our writers keep in mind the assignment delivery time. Because we care about clients, we go that extra mile to make sure you do not face those consequences. Whatever the deadline, we promise our clients a prompt delivery.
Are our charges too cheap for you to believe? Here at Assignments Ace, we offer quality assignment help at affordable prices. Our prices are substantive to cater to all students. Every time you place your assignment order with us, you are guaranteed a 15% discount.In addition, new clients enjoy a discount of 30% when placing their first order with us.
Customer Support 24/7
Do you have any queries for us? Or do you want to consult with our expert academic writers? Go ahead and contact us. We have 24/7 online friendly customer service. Whatever time of the day or night, we are always available for you. You can chat with us via our online chat services or contact us via our email, email@example.com.
Try it now!
How it works?
Follow these simple steps to get your paper done
Place your order
Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.
Proceed with the payment
Choose the payment system that suits you most.
Receive the final file
Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.
Our assignments help website is the most internationally sought-after site because we offer a wide range of top-quality services at low prices. Our proud history as an assignment help company stretches back nine years. We do offer Top Quality, Well-Researched Papers and Online classes to help students internationally. We do both of these things at cheap affordable prices by offering up to a 30% discount.
Writing an essay is one of the most tedious tasks that require a lot of concentration and research. Writing an essay takes hours and even up days. We offer the best custom writing service and have your best interests in mind. Most online writing industries do not have qualified writers and are just after your money. Worry less, our writers who have enough experience are ready to give you the help you need. Our writers are carefully selected and undergo some tests to prove their professionalism.
Are you applying for a college? We help students join their dream college by writing for them strong admission papers that showcases their qualities and personalities. An admission essay is an essay or other written statement by a candidate, often a potential student enrolling in a college, university, or graduate school. We utilize statements of purpose, personal statements, and personal essays to make a compelling case by stating your leadership activities, education, accomplishments, and professional background.
Editing and Proofreading
We offer an abundance of online proofreading and editing services for our clients. By definition, proofreading is the final surface-level check done on a document. Other academic writing companies offer editing and proofreading as separate services. At our assignment help website, we offer editing and proofreading services as one complete package at affordable cheap prices. Grab your 30% Coupon if you order today!!!
Are you a student pursuing an MBA in business, no need to look any further? We offer the best assignment help as we have the top niche MBA business writers who will give you A+ assignments. Over the years, our experts have helped students accomplish their academic dreams. We have helped thousands of students complete their business assignments with confidence.Grab your 30% Coupon if you order today!!!